New Canadian Doctors Group Aims to Ban Guns From Licensed Owners
02 February 2019
5 min read
TheGunBlog.ca — A new group of Canadian doctors backed by the country’s main medical organizations is urging the government to ban and seize guns from federally licensed hunters, farmers and sport shooters. Its leader compared new restrictions to a “preventative vaccine” against a disease.
Canadians deserve to be safe from guns. No civilian needs access to guns. The harms far outweigh any benefit. The evidence is clear. Sign the petition to ban handguns: petition e-1923. Write to your MP. #ThisIsOurLane @BillBlair @JohnTory @JustinTrudeau https://t.co/9HDId4PdH3
— Najma Ahmed (@najmadoc) January 15, 2019
Ahmed is a trauma surgeon at Saint Michael’s Hospital in Toronto who worked to save gunshot victims after July’s attack on Danforth Avenue. She blocked TheGunBlog.ca (@TheGunBlog) from seeing what she writes on Twitter on Jan. 8 after we retweeted another of her posts with a comment.
‘Not Evidence-Based Practise’
The group Ahmed is spearheading seeks new prohibitions and “an amnesty program to recover firearms currently in circulation,” according to its position statement. The doctors support Bill C-71, the government’s planned law against men and women with police-authorized firearm licences.
“This is Not evidenced-based practise!” said a Facebook comment today by Phil Hutchings, whose profile says he’s a registered nurse in Ontario. “Please review the real statistics and facts regarding firearms.”
More Canadian Than Hockey
Hunting is at the heart of Canadian culture, and target shooting is one of the country’s safest and most-popular sports. More men and women have a firearm licence than play golf, hockey, football, tennis or who ski.
In addition to the country’s record high of 2.2 million permit holders, millions more family and friends of all ages hunt and shoot safely and responsibly under their supervision.
Hunting with family. Doesn't get much better! ❤️ pic.twitter.com/UpEeGFUxLq
— Jim Shockey (@JimShockey_) January 27, 2019
Guns Save Lives on Danforth
The Danforth attacker — who ignored the handgun ban that applied to him — didn’t send more shredded bodies to Ahmed because he was stopped by police who shot back. The murderer then killed himself.
Almost 100,000 men and women, mainly police, are authorized or required to carry loaded guns every day to protect the public, including doctors campaigning to disarm them and their families.
Ahmed vs. Kiejko
Senior police leaders oppose new bans. All guns are banned already for everyone under threat of prison unless they get police or military permission. Civilians must pass safety courses, tests, reference checks and a daily background check.
Success for Ahmed would end the athletic careers of Lynda Kiejko, an Olympic pistol shooter, and her fellow competitors on Team Canada. It would prevent farmers from protecting their crops, and cause communities who depend on hunting to starve.
Update April 6: Ahmed’s group registered with Canada’s Commissioner of Lobbying using the address and phone number of St. Michael’s Hospital.
.@TeamCanada 🇨🇦 teammate Lynda Kiejko (@Cdnshootingstar) wins women's 10m pistol event at 2018 Championship of the Americas! …with that she also wins Canada a 2019 Pan Am Games AND a 2020 Olympic Games quota spot! #TeamCanada #Tokyo2020 pic.twitter.com/pcGUCRtaGR
— Allan Harding (@alharding) November 4, 2018
“Gun violence is not random,” Ahmed said in a Jan. 31 article for the University of Toronto Faculty of Medicine, where she is a professor in the Department of Surgery. “Instead, just like any disease, it has its own epidemiology and risk factors. And its version of a preventative vaccine would include stricter laws governing civilian ownership of handguns, social programs to support at risk youth and investment in more effective policing to prevent the illegal trafficking of guns.”
Ahmed’s group said its position paper was endorsed by the following organizations:
- The College of Family Physicians of Canada
- Canadian Association of General Surgeons
- Canadian Association of Emergency Physicians
- Canadian Paediatric Society
- Ontario Medical Association
- Alberta Medical Association
- Trauma Association of Canada
“Physicians and health workers from across Canada will be holding a National Day of Action in communities from coast to coast on April 3rd, 2019 to call for stronger gun control laws, including passage of Bill C-71 and a handgun assault weapons ban,” the group said.
Great call this evening with leaders from across the country – getting ready to launch advocacy group – Canadian Doctors for Protection from Guns.
Injuries, suicide, homocide from guns is preventable public health crisis. #ThisisOurLane. Stay tuned. Join in, make a difference
— Najma Ahmed (@najmadoc) February 1, 2019
Ahmed began her campaign against Canada’s most-lawful demographic in mid-November as the Coalition for Gun Control kicked off a new disarmament effort.
- Nov. 15: Opinion article in the Globe and Mail.
- Nov. 19: First tweet mentioning guns. (Click here to see all.)
- Nov. 20: Tweet Coalition for Gun Control disarmament campaign.
- Jan. 28: Facebook page, initially using Ahmed’s Twitter photo.
- Jan. 30: Global News profile.
- Jan. 31: Article at University of Toronto Faculty of Medicine, where Ahmed is a professor and vice-chair in the Department of Surgery.
- Jan. 31: Twitter: “Great call this evening with leaders from across the country – getting ready to launch advocacy group – Canadian Doctors for Protection from Guns.”
Update Feb. 3: “Somehow I am feeling betrayed yet again by my colleagues,” Ozzy Ramirez, an emergency-room physician in Ontario, tweeted Feb. 3 in response to this article. “Rather than attacking root cause, they want to deprive me of my property and enjoyment of an activity that I share with my entire family. This doctor owns guns and is not a threat. Why pick on the likes of me?”
Somehow I am feeling betrayed yet again by my colleagues. Rather than attacking root cause, they want to deprive me of my property and enjoyment of an activity that I share with my entire family. This doctor owns guns and is not a threat. Why pick on the likes of me? https://t.co/DONgFwhUiZ
— Ozzy Ramirez (@ozzyramirezmd) February 3, 2019
About zero people die each year at Canada’s 1,400 shooting ranges. That compares with more than 30,000 annual deaths by doctor error, the Huffington Post reported in October 2015, before the current opioid epidemic.
“Patients suffered potentially preventable harm in more than 138,000 hospitalizations in Canada, or about 1 in 18 hospitalizations,” the Canadian Institute for Health Information said in October 2016.
— HuffPost Canada (@HuffPostCanada) October 24, 2015
Yet most firearm owners refuse to support gun-rights groups or media. They keep quiet or bicker with each other online while prohibitionists work together on media campaigns and elect allies into power. Many gun owners vote for anti-gun candidates and parties, such as the current government.
Doctors Against Rights
Some doctors’s groups have lobbied against firearm owners for years. The Canadian Paediatric Society calls for prohibitions on the sale and possession of semi-automatic guns and “the removal of firearms from the homes of adolescents and children.”
“Advocacy has always been an essential part of the practice of medicine,” Trevor Young, the dean of the University of Toronto Faculty of Medicine, said in a Nov. 21 article on the faculty website, mentioning Ahmed’s work. He was responding to the U.S. National Rifle Association asking self-important anti-gun doctors to “stay in their lane.”
Someone should tell self-important anti-gun doctors to stay in their lane. Half of the articles in Annals of Internal Medicine are pushing for gun control. Most upsetting, however, the medical community seems to have consulted NO ONE but themselves. https://t.co/oCR3uiLtS7
— NRA (@NRA) November 7, 2018
- Share, forward, re-post this article. (See it on Medium.)
- Invite your doctor to the range.
- Update Feb. 5: File a complaint with the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario. (See the CCFR’s follow up to this article.)
- E-mail the doctors’s groups to express your concern. Ask them to investigate if doctors advocating the seizure of your survival gear or property is in line with medical ethics. Optional bcc: [email protected]
- How Quiet Gun Owners Become Former Gun Owners
- Three Top Cops Don’t Support Banning Guns From Lawful Owners
- First Take: Inside Today’s Study of ‘Firearm Injuries’ in Youth
- Website: Doctors for Responsible Gun Ownership
Corrections Feb. 3: Corrects name of Canadian Paediatric Society. Feb. 4: Corrects spelling of “preventative.”
- April 6: Adds that group is a registered lobby group.
- June 6: Removes Action Step added Feb. 5 to file a complaint.
© 2015 - 2021 TheGunBlog.ca