Liberal MPs Attack Scheer Over University Club Range Day
TheGunBlog.ca — At least three Canadian government MPs and a staffer sought to associate the Conservative leader of the opposition, Andrew Scheer, with terrorism and mass murder because Carleton University’s Conservative club organized a range day today with an AR-15 rifle.
“Disappointed that @AndrewScheer’s Conservatives are fundraising off of the AR-15 which was used in the recent shooting in Christchurch, NZ,” Peter Schiefke, a parliamentary secretary to the prime minister and Liberal member of parliament in Quebec, said on Twitter last night.
Schiefke assisted Minister Bill Blair last year in meeting with gun owners across Canada to examine the mass gun confiscations that Blair is now preparing.
“Unbelievable,” tweeted Chris Bittle, the Deputy Government House Leader and the Liberal MP for St. Catharines, Ontario. “@AndrewScheer Conservatives are having a fundraiser by firing the same type of gun used in NZ Mosque terror attack and Sandy Hook (and so many other mass shootings) #cdnpoli”
Blaming one person or group because of a random relation to another person or group is one of the most basic flaws of reasoning, but it’s emotionally powerful.
The so-called “guilt-by-association fallacy” is a favourite tactic of firearm prohibitionists and genocidal tyrants seeking to scapegoat their enemies as a prelude to confiscation or extermination, or both. But it’s rare for it to be weaponized so dishonestly and personalized so directly.
Smear and Slander
For more than a year, the Liberal government has promoted Bill C-71, its planned law against hunters, farmers and sport shooters, by suggesting a link between violent offenders and Canada’s 2.2 million men and women with firearm licences.
The Liberals have failed to show any evidence of a link because none exists. The government is using the same tactic as it prepares mass gun confiscation from lawful owners.
The slander has angered gun owners across the country. Their rights to dignity, culture, heritage, protection, privacy and property are now critical election issues for hundreds of thousands of voters.
The latest smears come after The Canadian Press quoted Liberal Prime Minister Justin Trudeau as telling supporters Feb. 1 his party would “stay positive” in the face of “negative, divisive campaigns” in this year’s election.
The Carleton Campus Conservatives in Ottawa published a Facebook invitation on April 1 for a range day today. It mentioned the chance to fire an AR-15, a popular rifle for Canada’s millions of shooters and one of the world’s bestselling firearms. Several other guns were also featured in the invitation.
The event was at Stittsville Shooting Ranges, the same location as an annual Parliamentary Day at the Range for MPs and staff from all parties.
Hunting and sport shooting are at the heart of Canadian culture and heritage. More Canadian men and women have a firearm licence authorized by the federal police than play golf or hockey.
Photo of Invitation
Vandenbeld: Good Message?
“[email protected]’s Conservative Party is inviting members to shoot an AR-15 as a social outing,” Anita Vandenbeld, a Liberal MP in Ottawa, tweeted 6 minutes after Bittle. “This is the same type of weapon used in the terrorist attack in Christchurch, NZ and at school shootings including Sandy Hook. Is this the message a political leader should be sending?!”
‘White Nationalist Hate’
Ministry staff also jumped in.
Rosalyn Stevens, whose Twitter and LinkedIn bios say she works in the office of Maryam Monsef, the Minister of International Development and Minister for Women and Gender Equality, said in the first (subsequently deleted) of four tweets on Scheer and his party today:
“In less than an hour, @AndrewScheer’s Conservatives are making a play date & fundraiser out of shooting AR-15 assault rifles. These are the kind used in mass shootings, the very kind used in the New Zealand terrorist attack that Scheer would not call out as white nationalist hate”
The three MP tweets had more than 750 replies as of 11 p.m. Toronto time today, almost all of them critical.
“Dear MP Schiefke, It’s surprising to see your fake smear after you’ve just spent the past several months with Minister Bill Blair meeting safe and responsible gun owners across Canada,” said TheGunBlog.ca. “Your comment casts doubt on the value of the meetings and the intentions of your government.”
TheGunBlog.ca also replied to Bittle and Vandenbeld.
- “Am I wrong that the AR-15 is just a civilian variant of the same C7 gun class that’s a standard infantry weapon in the Canadian military?” Jonathan Kay, an editor with Quillette magazine, replied to Bittle today. “Why we would let us some scumbag mass murderer on the other side of the planet dictate taboos in Canada ?”
- “Canada has a long history of responsible gun ownership,” Kyle Mirecki, a lawyer and former Conservative staffer, responded to Vandenbeld. “Hosting events celebrating and supporting the segment of the population, like myself, who own assault rifles and use them responsibly is not controversial. That’s the message he is sending.”
- “Are you aware that you flew in the exact aircraft terrorists flew into the twin towers and killed 2,996 people on 9/11?” tweeted Scott Pulvermacher in reply to Vandenbeld. “Should you be public persecuted for doing nothing wrong? Nothing illegal? There is no difference. Grow up. Thank you Mr. Sheer and enjoy your time! 👏”
Carleton University Firearms Association
Update on April 8: “We are hoping to host other campus political parties at the range in hopes of educating students on safe firearms handling,” Kelvin Jiang, the vice president of the Carleton University Firearms Association, told TheGunBlog.ca by e-mail on April 8.
The association is a member of the Canadian University Shooting Federation and said it ran the range day for the Carleton Conservatives.
Original Tweets, TheGunBlog Replies
- April 8 at 20:30 Toronto time: Adds comment by Carleton University Firearms Association.
- June 3: Adds photo of Stevens’s deleted tweet.